Shopify VS Squarespace SEO

Shopify and Squarespace are popular eCommerce solutions for businesses looking to create successful online stores. Both offer robust tools and features to help you build an effective website, including customization options and content management systems. However, each has its own unique advantages and disadvantages when it comes to search engine optimization (SEO).

In this article, we’ll break down the features of Shopify vs Squarespace SEO to help you determine which platform can best serve your business needs.

Most Important Things for SEO

When comparing Shopify vs Squarespace SEO, there are several factors to consider. They include:

Load Times & Core Web Vitals

shopify vs squarespace seo

Load times are an important SEO factor since page speed affects user experience, which can directly impact a website’s ranking in search engine results pages (SERPs).

Core web vitals are also a key SEO factor, as they are part of Google’s ranking algorithm. Core web vitals measure loading, interactivity, and visual stability and include First Contentful Paint (FCP), Largest Contentful Paint (LCP), and Cumulative Layout Shift (CLS). FCP measures page loading speed, LCP measures how much content loads before the user can interact with the page, and CLS measures how stable the page layout is.

In terms of load times, Shopify features a powerful technology stack that helps to make pages load quickly. This includes its own content delivery network (CDN) and the popular Liquid templating language. This language helps to speed up page loading times by pre-fetching information and caching assets.

Shopify also has a number of built-in tools for optimizing core web vitals. These include the ability to control page speed and reduce render-blocking scripts. Additionally, Shopify’s built-in AMP features can help improve user experience on mobile devices, which is essential for SEO success.

Squarespace also has powerful tools for optimizing core web vitals. This includes its integrated optimization engine, which is designed to improve page loading times and reduce render-blocking scripts. Squarespace also offers a feature called “Lazy Load”, which only loads images when they are visible on the screen. This helps to speed up page loading times and reduce overall file size.

As far as load times and core web vitals go, both Shopify and Squarespace offer powerful tools for optimizing your website’s performance. However, Shopify has more advanced and integrated tools and apps within its app store that gives you more control over your website’s performance.

shopify seo or squarespace seo

SEO-Friendly URLs

URLs are important to SEO for several reasons. First, they act as the link between a web page and the search engine. This means that your URLs need to be well-structured and descriptive so that search engines can easily index them. Additionally, URLs are often used in the SERPs as part of the page title or description which means they should also include relevant keywords for better visibility.

Shopify features SEO-friendly URLs out of the box. These URLs can be customized to include relevant keywords and are designed to be easily readable by both people and search engines. Additionally, Shopify also has a number of built-in features for managing URLs, such as the ability to redirect old URLs to new ones for SEO purposes.

However, it's worth noting that Shopify offers very limited customizations for URLs. This is because Shopify uses its own system for generating URLs. This means you may need to undergo a rigorous process to customize URLs, depending on your business needs. 

which one is better

Squarespace also offers SEO-friendly URLs out of the box. It also has advanced tools for customizing your URLs, such as an editor that allows you to add keywords and structure your URLs in a way that is friendly to both search engines and people.

However, Squarespace does not offer custom redirects as Shopify does. This means that if you want to redirect old URLs, you’ll need to use an external tool or plugin. It also does not offer any built-in tools for managing URLs, so you may want to consider Shopify if you need more control over your URLs.

Ease of Use

Ease of use is an important factor to consider when choosing a platform for SEO purposes. Shopify and Squarespace are both designed to be user-friendly, but they each have their own unique features that make them more or less suitable for certain tasks.

Shopify is known for its ease of use. It features a drag-and-drop editor and a wide range of ready-made templates to help you quickly create an attractive website. It also has powerful tools in the App Store that can be used to optimize your site for SEO purposes.

Even if you want to migrate your WordPress blog to Shopify or transfer your existing website to Shopify, the process is fairly straightforward. The platform has many apps and tools available to make the process easier.

From a user-friendliness perspective, Shopify is a great option. Its user interface is intuitive, making it easy to customize your website without writing a single line of code. This is the factor that makes it a clear winner when comparing Woocommerce SEO vs Shopify SEO.

squarespace seo vs shopify pros and cons

Squarespace is generally easier to use than Shopify, thanks to its integrated optimization engine and easy-to-use editor. Additionally, Squarespace offers more design customization options, and its support team is generally helpful in assisting users with any issues they may encounter.

Squarespace also offers an extensive library of video tutorials and knowledge-base articles that can help you set up your website quickly and easily. Even if you are the most novice of users, you will be able to get up and running quickly with Squarespace.

Its interface is well-organized and intuitive. All essential features are easily accessible, and there is a search bar at the top to help you quickly find what you are looking for.

Overall, Squarespace carries the day when it comes to ease of use. It's more intuitive and offers more customization options, making it a great choice for those who are new to web design.

Technical SEO

Technical SEO is the process of optimizing website structure and infrastructure to help search engine spiders crawl, index, and rank pages. It is an important part of any SEO strategy, and both Shopify and Squarespace offer features that can help you optimize your website. Let's look at the features of each in detail.

shopify vs squarespace seowhich one is better

Shopify offers a range of features that can help you optimize your website. It has a built-in sitemap generator, which can help search engines quickly index your website's pages. This can be a great way to get your website noticed by search engines. It also has options for customizing URLs and redirects, which can help make sure that pages are properly indexed and ranked.

Shopify also allows you to add schema markup and meta tags, which can help improve the visibility of your website in search engine results. Schema markup is code that can help search engines better understand the content on your website, and meta tags are text snippets that can enhance the visibility of title tags and descriptions.

Other technical SEO features you will find on Shopify include:

Robots.txt file

By default, Shopify includes a robots.txt file that can help you control how search engine spiders crawl your website. This is great for preventing certain pages or files from being indexed.

Hreflang tags

This tag helps search engines know when to serve content in different languages. Shopify supports this feature, so you can make sure users are served the right version of your website in their language.

Redirects

shopify seo or squarespace seo cons

One of the most useful features of Shopify is that you can manage 301 and 302 redirects directly from the platform. This ensures visitors are directed to the right page when a URL has changed or been removed. 

By taking advantage of this feature, you can ensure that no visitors land on a 404 page, which can negatively affect your SEO.

Product structured data

Shopify does a good job of marking up product pages with structured data. This includes information like product names, prices, availability, and more. This helps search engines understand the context of your product pages and can help them rank higher in search results.

shopify seo vs squarespace seo pros and cons of each

Breadcrumb List structured data

This type of structured data helps search engines understand the page hierarchy on your website. It also helps them understand how your content is organized, which can help improve the visibility of your pages in search engine results.

Squarespace also offers a range of features that can help you optimize for SEO. It integrates easily with Google Search Console and other webmaster tools, which can help you monitor your website's performance and identify any technical SEO issues that may be holding it back.

Squarespace also allows users to hide a page from search engines. Maybe you don't want a certain page to be indexed, or you want to test a page without it being crawled. With Squarespace, you can easily do this with no technical knowledge required.

This platform also creates sitemaps automatically, which can help search engines quickly index your website's content. It has an automatic markup feature, which can add schema markup to your pages in the background. This helps search engines better understand the context and content of your website, which can help improve rankings.

You can easily clean URLs with Squarespace, so you don't have to worry about long, unwieldy URLs. This can also help search engines better understand the structure of your website and how pages are related.

squarespace vs shopify seo

Squarespace has a Google-rich image search feature, which can help your product images show up in image search results. This can be a great way to drive more organic traffic to your website. It allows you to customize image titles, descriptions, and more.

Both Shopify and Squarespace offer a range of features that can help you optimize your website for SEO. However, Shopify has more features tailored to technical SEO, which are complemented by a plethora of Shopify apps specifically designed to help improve SEO. Ultimately, Shopify is the better option for those serious about optimizing their website for search engine visibility.

Indexation & Crawl Budget Optimization

Indexation is the process of getting your website pages indexed by search engine spiders. This is important because it helps ensure search engines are aware of your content and can serve it up in results when people search for your target keywords.

Crawl budget optimization is the process of optimizing how often search engine spiders crawl your website. This ensures that they don’t waste their time on pages that don’t need to be indexed.

Shopify has several out-of-the-box features that help you with indexation and crawl budget optimization. These include a robots.txt file, which allows you to control which pages get indexed, and an XML sitemap to help search engine spiders find all the important information on your site. You can also use Shopify’s Accelerated Mobile Pages (AMP) technology, which helps speed up page loading times for mobile users.

To help optimize the crawl budget of your store, Shopify also offers the ability to set up redirects and canonical URLs, two important elements of SEO. Setting up redirects ensures that traffic is sent to the correct page, and setting up canonical URLs tells search engines which version of the page to index.

squarespace vs shopify seo pros

Squarespace offers several SEO-oriented features that help with indexation and crawl budget optimization. It has a built-in XML sitemap generator that helps make sure all your important content is discoverable by search engine spiders. This is especially helpful if you have a large website with lots of pages.

This platform sets automatic redirects. This simple yet powerful feature helps you improve your SEO rankings. It also offers the ability to set up canonical URLs, which signals search engines on how to index and rank content.

Its automatic tagging feature helps you optimize your indexing for image and video content, which are often overlooked when optimizing a website. It also has an AMP feature that helps speed up page loading times for mobile users.

Thanks to its robust indexation and crawl budget optimization features, Squarespace beats Shopify in this category. However, as Shopify SEO experts we recommend the use of Shopify apps to supplement its core indexation features and help you get better results.

squarespace seo vs seo shopify pros and cons of each

Customization

Customization is an integral part of SEO. It helps you make sure that your website content is relevant to the keyword or topic you are targeting, as well as ensures a better user experience for those who visit your web page.

Shopify offers an extensive range of customization options that can be used to help optimize your website for SEO. You can easily customize meta tags, page titles, and more. You can also use Shopify's drag-and-drop website builder to create custom pages with content optimized for search engine visibility.

Furthermore, there is a plethora of apps available on Shopify’s App Store that can help you further customize your website for SEO. This includes apps that allow you to automatically generate sitemaps, analyze website performance, and optimize content for targeted keywords.

Shopify themes are also easily customizable, allowing you to make changes to the design of your website to help increase its visibility in search engine rankings.

Squarespace has fewer customization options available than Shopify, but the ones it does have are powerful. Its website builder allows you to easily create custom pages with optimized content and Meta tags. It also has a wide range of themes that are designed to be SEO-friendly, allowing you to customize your website without any coding experience.

Shopify is the undisputed king of customization when it comes to SEO, offering more options for customizing your website for search engine optimization.

Apps & Plugins

squarespace seo vs shopify seo

Apps and plugins are an important part of SEO. They allow you to add extra features and functionality to your websites, such as analytics tools and plug-ins for monitoring your website’s performance.

Shopify offers an extensive App Store where you can find hundreds of apps and plugins that help with SEO. These include tools for keyword optimization, content analysis, social media optimization, and more. In addition, Shopify’s app store also includes plugins for popular CMSs like WordPress and Drupal. For instance, TinyPNG integrates seamlessly with Shopify and allows you to optimize your website’s images for faster loading times.

Squarespace has an extensions marketplace that contains a very limited number of third-party extensions. This means you are unlikely to find the same variety of SEO tools and plugins as you would on Shopify. Also, some essential extensions are only available in select countries, which further limits your options.

Overall, when it comes to apps and plugins, Shopify has a clear advantage over Squarespace. The sheer number and variety of options available in the Shopify App Store make it an ideal platform for eCommerce businesses looking to maximize their SEO potential. 

While Squarespace offers some decent extensions, it lags behind Shopify in terms of usability, selection, and availability.

Security

There is no denying that website security is a major factor in SEO. Not only do search engines take into account the security measures you have taken to protect your website, but they also look at how quickly you respond to malicious attacks and resolve any vulnerabilities in your site’s coding.

Shopify is well known for its secure hosting platform, which includes a range of features such as malware scanning, automated backups, and SSL certificates. Shopify also has dedicated teams monitoring its systems 24/7 to ensure your website is always secure and compliant with the latest security protocols.

squarespace vs shopify seo cons

Additionally, Shopify has a technical support team on hand to help you out with any security issues that may arise.

Squarespace does not offer the same level of protection as Shopify, but it is still more than capable of keeping your website secure. The platform offers automated backups, SSL certificates, and two-factor authentication for added protection. It also provides daily malware scans and has a dedicated team of security experts monitoring its systems to prevent any malicious attacks.

Both Shopify and Squarespace offer robust security protocols, which means you can rest assured that your website is protected from any potential threats.

Pros and Cons Of Shopify and Squarespace for SEO

Using Shopify and Squarespace for SEO has a fair share of pros and cons. You need to weigh the options carefully before deciding which is best for your needs.

Shopify Pros

Built-in Mobile Optimization

The Shopify platform offers built-in mobile optimization, which makes it easy to ensure your site looks great on any device. This helps boost your SEO efforts because Google has started to consider mobile-friendliness as an important ranking factor.

shopify vs squarespace seo pros and cons

Robust Analytics & Reporting Tools

Shopify includes powerful analytics and reporting tools. This allows you to track things like website visits, sales, and other data points, which can be invaluable for SEO.

SEO Apps Available

Shopify has a selection of SEO-focused apps that can help you with things like meta tags and keyword research. These are great for people who don’t have the time or expertise to do all the work themselves.

Optimized CSS & HTML5 coding

Shopify is designed with SEO in mind, and they use optimized CSS and HTML5 coding to ensure your pages load quickly and efficiently. This helps improve your search engine rankings.

shopify vs squarespace seo which one is better

Shopify Cons

Customization Limitations

Shopify also has some limits when it comes to customization. For instance, its complicated to make changes to the code in order to create unique designs or functionality. This can limit your SEO efforts as you won’t be able to customize certain elements of the website for search engine optimization. However, we have a team of experts that can work around this limitation and deliver the best results.

Limited Structured Data Support

Shopify’s structured data support is also limited. This can make it difficult to properly optimize your content for search engine results pages (SERPs).

Squarespace Pros

Intuitive Editor & Easy-to-Use Interface

Squarespace has a very intuitive editor and easy-to-use interface, which makes it easy to build and update your website quickly. This is great for SEO since you won’t have to spend a lot of time learning how to use the platform, which in turn allows you to publish content fast.

Unlimited Storage & Bandwidth

Squarespace also offers unlimited storage and bandwidth, which is great for SEO. You won’t have to worry about your website slowing down or crashing due to a lack of resources.

Integration with Social Media

shopify seo vs squarespace seo which one is better

Squarespace has great integration with social media, which makes it easy to share your content and engage with customers. This can help boost your SEO efforts by improving your visibility on the web.

Squarespace Cons

Limited Apps

Its extension library is also limited compared to Shopify. This means you won’t have access to some of the more advanced SEO-focused apps available on the Shopify platform.

Website Speed

The average website speed on Squarespace is 3-5 seconds. Even though we can't dismiss this as slow, it is not competitive when compared to Shopify's average website speed of 1-2 seconds. Website speed is an important ranking factor, so this can negatively impact your SEO efforts.

Shopify vs. Squarespace SEO - Conclusion

Choosing between Shopify and Squarespace for SEO depends on your needs and preferences. 

If you need a powerful, customizable platform with access to advanced apps, then Shopify is the better option. On the other hand, if you’re looking for an easy-to-use platform with social media integration and unlimited storage, then Squarespace is a good choice. Ultimately, you should weigh the pros and cons of both platforms carefully before making your decision.

shopify vs squarespace seo pros

Partner With A World-Class Shopify SEO Agency

At GoldenWeb, we know you have a lot on your plate, and focusing on your Shopify SEO can be a hassle. We want to be part of your success, so let us take care of the hard part.

At GoldenWeb we start every new project with a full Shopify SEO audit that goes deep into your store and uncovers over 285 SEO & CRO growth opportunities. This includes on-page optimization, link building, and technical SEO. We then develop a tailored strategy designed to drive your store's organic revenue growth.

We provide a free mini-audit that analyses your store and provides insights into how to improve your Shopify SEO. Book yours today to get started!

Deven Davis

RomaDesignerJewelry.com

"GoldenWeb’s work has been amazing for us.

We already had a decent base with content and structure, but their work has positioned us to continue to make gains in very competitive areas."

Alex Smith

ShopSolarKits.com

"Benjamin and his team have been great to work with, have proven themselves with a ton of results.

Benjamin goes out of his way to provide value in all areas of the business as he's an operator himself."